Connect with us

Detroit Red Wings

Trading for Tkachuk Makes Sense, But Red Wings Aren’t the Favorite



matthew tkachuk, calgary flames

When Detroit Red Wings Steve Yzerman last talked to the media, he thought the dealing was done. He shows a roster with 26 NHL players, plus defenseman Simon Edvinsson who will probably make the team. If a prospect like Jonatan Berggren or Elmer Soderblom earns a place, interesting decisions will have to be made.

“I’m pretty content right now,” Yzerman said, “to go into training camp with the group we have.”

Then, he gave himself an out clause.

“But I wouldn’t be doing my job if I wasn’t exploring, if there’s any other opportunities out there, by trade,” Yzerman said. “I wouldn’t want to sign another significant free agent and put myself in position where I have to trade somebody for whatever reason because that’s not a good time to do it. But I’m always looking at ways to try to get better.”

That’s why you can assume Yzerman placed a call to the Calgary Flames about Matthew Tkachuk. That’s who Yzerman is. He leaves no opportunity unexplored. Tkachuk is one of the rarest of players in the NHL. Last season, Tkachuk scored 42 goals while playing the irritating style that puts him on the list of hardest players to play against. He would be an exceptional addition to Detroit’s rebuild.

Since Tkachuk told the Flames he doesn’t want to stay with them long-term, social media has been alive with trade possibilities in several cities.

But here are some factors to consider before drawing any conclusion about what the Red Wings’ chances are of landing Tkachuk.

Who Flames Will Want

First, what we are hearing is that the Flames will want a top forward, a premium prospect and a first-round pick.

The Flames will be looking for players like Lucas Raymond or Edvinsson, maybe Elmer Soderblom, etc.
Calgary once acquired a young Jarome Iginla for Joe Nieuwendyk and they will be trying to replicate that deal.

Yzerman is not likely to part with Raymond and Edvinsson.

Second, those who like the idea of moving Tyler Bertuzzi in a trade for Tkachuk have to consider that the Flames aren’t going to be interested in another player with a chance to be a UFA next summer. Second, Bertuzzi’s unvaccinated status could cause even more problems if he is on a Canadian team. Of course that is all dependent upon what Canada’s vaccination rules will be in 2022-23. We simply don’t know what those will be. But the Flames, having lost Gaudreau and now Tkachuk, will be looking for players with term on their contract.

Also, Tkachuk has the leverage here because most teams will want to sign him long-term. We don’t know know how he feels about Detroit. Would he want to be part of a rebuild? He is only 24. Tkachuk knows Michigan because he played two seasons for the U.S. National Team Development Program. He knows Red Wings captain Dylan Larkin. That’s a plus.

Big Ticket

Tkachuk is also probably going to want a long-term contract in the $9-10 million range. Remember, he is a restricted free agent so the acquiring team needs cap space for him this season. Depending upon who goes back in the deal, the Red Wings could suddenly be pushed up against the salary cap. Detroit Hockey Now projects the Red Wings will have about $7.5 million in cap space at the start of the season.

The other issue in play here is that there will be several other teams bidding for Tkachuk. Some believe the St. Louis Blues are one of the favorites because Tkachuk is from St. Louis.

BetMGM Sportsbook

States: AZ, NJ, PA, IN, CO, MI, VA, WV


Already, we are starting to hear potential offers of top players like Robert Thomas or Jordan Kyrou. The New Jersey Devils general manager Tom Fitzgerald is related to the Tkachuk family and there has been speculation about the Devils offering Jesper Brett. He’s a 23-year-old Swedish forward who scored 27 goals last season. Kyrou, 24, also scored 27 goals last season.

The Devils were also trying to land Johnny Gaudreau. They have plenty of cap space.

Plus, Matthew Tkachuk may want to play with his brother, Brady, in Ottawa. They suddenly are willing to spend and they have a cache of young talent.

The Red Wings are probably interested in Tkachuk. But to acquire him, it will require Yzerman to give up a players who are in his rebuild plans. That’s why the Red Wings are probably not among the favorites to land him

Welcome to your new home for Detroit Red Wings breaking news, analysis and opinion. Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter and don't forget to subscribe to DHN+ for all of our members-only content from Kevin Allen, Bob Duff and the National Hockey Now network.
Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Calgary is a weak bargaining position (Tkachuk isn’t signed long-term is starting his walk year. It’s post Gaudreau leaving for nothing. And timing is late as it’s after free agent money has been spent limiting roster spots and cap space) and it’s getting weaker by the day–for example the Preds just bowed out of any chance by signing Nino Niederreiter for 2yrs x 4M. The Stars look to be next as they have Oettinger coming off his ELC and have to reserve for Roope Hintz next year. The Jets cap room will disappear with Pierre-Luc Dubois. Plus if Tkachuk isn’t traded before the season his rental return value also starts dissipating.

In fact, teams with greater than 9.5M on the cap: NJD 9.59M & 17/23 spots filled, Det 10.3M & 22/23 spots filled, Chi 10.59M & 19/23, NYI, Dal, Ott, Win, Buf, Ariz, and ANH.

Yet, even teams that look like they have cap space have to account for ELC’s or young players that are due large raises in the next two years: Ottawa’s Stutzle & DeBrincat (his actual salary is 9M this year but his AAV only 6.4M). NYI and Noah Dobson. NJD and Jesper Bratt.

But that might not stop a team from acting and then having to trade a piece off later. For example the rumor is the NJD are negotiating and the package is Alexander Holtz, Nolan Foote, a 2023 1st round (unprotected), but additionally Calgary wants Jesper Bratt and NJD won’t trade him. NJD are offering Yegor Sharangovich instead.

That’s a substantial offer: but that’s not insurmountable though. A package from Detroit might look like Vrana, Zadina, Albert Johansson, and a 2024 1st (unprotected).

…but the Blues…this isn’t NHL 2022 with the cap turned off. Tarasenko’s got a NTC is in the exact same position as Tkachuk, while NTC’s extend to: Saad, Schenn, Faulk, Krug, Parayko, and Leddy. Would anyone waive their clauses to go to Alberta this winter? Besides, the Blues currently have 625k in space: where’s the 9.5M in projected cap space coming from? Did Gaudreau being from Jersey help the NJD to get him–and they didn’t have to give up anyone in a trade.

So no, I think the Flames will have to settle for less.

Gordon Cheswick

Contracts are NO problem. If the Best fir Tkachuk is doable – each team signs them – then trades then. I think T is worth $9MM/yr. I think Bert is worth $6MM. Add in a Hronek and a Johansson and a ‘second’ rounder in 2024, and the DRW side is done! As for T @$9MM – add in ILYA NIKOLAYEV – and there is a blockbuster that everyone wants.


Trade Weegar on Florida forget anyone else

Mark W

Well it was a good plan.

Last edited 25 days ago by Mark W

Sign Up!

Get the very best in Detroit Red Wings and NHL breaking news, analysis and opinion delivered straight to your inbox.

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.